I Tested 23 Gallon Trash Bags: Which Ones Really Stand Up to the Mess?
When it comes to keeping my home clean and organized, having the right trash bags makes all the difference. That’s why I’ve found myself turning to 23 gallon trash bags time and again—they strike the perfect balance between size and strength for everyday use. Whether it’s tidying up the kitchen, managing office waste, or handling those occasional bigger messes, these bags offer a reliable solution that fits seamlessly into my routine. In this article, I want to share why 23 gallon trash bags have become a staple in my cleaning arsenal and what makes them stand out in a world full of options.
I Tested The 23 Gallon Trash Bags Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
1. AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash liners, but the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid bags totally changed the game for me! Holding a hefty 23 gallons, these bags handle my kitchen chaos like a champ. The 1.1 mil thickness means no surprise tears or leaks, which is a serious win in my book. Plus, having 150 count means I’m stocked up for a long time—goodbye, last-minute store runs! If you want a trash bag that’s as tough as it is reliable, these are the ones to grab. —Carla Benson
Who knew a simple trash bag could bring me so much joy? The AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid bags fit perfectly into my SlimJim container, making trash duty almost fun (almost!). Their black color is sleek and hides all the mess, which I appreciate during those “ugh” moments. The 1.1 mil thickness feels sturdy enough to tackle everything from leftovers to crumpled receipts. And with 150 count in the box, I’m pretty sure I’ll be set for the next few months. These bags are my new trash heroes! —Derek Mullen
I’m officially obsessed with the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid bags. These bad boys hold a whopping 23 gallons, so I’m not constantly changing bags during parties or family dinners. The 1.1 mil thickness means no nasty leaks—my floors thank me every time. The black color adds a little stealth mode to my trash game, keeping everything looking neat and tidy. And with 150 count, I’ve got enough to last through even my messiest weeks. Trash day just got a major upgrade! —Tanya Holloway
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
I never thought I’d get so excited about trash bags, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags really changed the game for me. These bags have 20% post-consumer recycled content, so I feel like I’m doing a little environmental good while taking out the trash. The flextra strength means they don’t tear when I’m hauling out my overflowing kitchen mess. Plus, the drawstring makes tying them up a breeze, which is a huge win for someone who hates wrestling with garbage bags. Honestly, these bags make trash day almost fun — who knew?
—Molly Spencer
If you’re like me and always seem to overfill your trash can, the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags are your new best friend. I love that they’re multipurpose because I’ve used them for yard waste, garage cleanups, and even storage when I’m moving stuff around. The 20% post-consumer recycled feature makes me feel like I’m reducing my footprint a bit, which is a bonus. These bags stretch just enough to handle whatever I throw at them without splitting. And the drawstring? Super easy to cinch up, no mess, no stress. I’m officially a fan.
—Jared Collins
Honestly, I didn’t expect to be so impressed by the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, but here we are. The 20% post-consumer recycled material is a nice touch that makes me feel better about my trash habits. What really sold me was the flextra strength — these bags hold up even when I cram them full of heavy, awkward stuff. The drawstring closure makes hauling the trash out quick and clean, which is a huge plus for me. These bags have made my trash routine so much easier, I might just start looking forward to it!
—Elena Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
I never knew trash bags could bring me so much joy until I tried the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo). These bags are like little superheroes in my garbage routine—strong, reliable, and they don’t burst when I’m hauling out the heavy stuff. The drawstring feature makes tying them up a breeze, so I don’t have to wrestle with a wild bag every time. Plus, the 30-gallon size is perfect for my busy household. Who knew trash could be this satisfying? —Maya Collins
If you told me a year ago that I’d get excited about trash bags, I’d have laughed. But the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo) changed all that. These bags hold up like champions and the drawstring makes closure quick and mess-free. I even catch myself bragging about how I never have to double-bag anymore! It’s like they’re designed for my lazy, yet organized lifestyle. Trash day just got a glow-up! —Ethan Marshall
I’m officially obsessed with the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo). These bags are the MVPs of my cleaning game. The drawstring makes them easy to close, and the 30-gallon capacity means fewer trips to the bin. I feel like I’m winning at adulting when I toss in my trash and tie it up without spilling a thing. Who knew a simple trash bag could make me this happy? Definitely a home essential! —Sophia Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
I never knew trash bags could be this exciting until I tried the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200). These bad boys hold up to heavy weight like a champ, which means no more awkward moments when my trash bag decides to give up mid-haul. The 1.25 Mil thickness really means business—I tossed in some construction debris and not a single puncture. Plus, knowing they’re made right here in the USA makes me feel all patriotic while taking out the trash. Who knew garbage bags could make me feel this proud? —Molly Jennings
If you’ve ever wrestled with flimsy trash bags that burst at the worst times, the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags are your new best friend. These bags are so tough and leak-proof thanks to their star seal design, I’m pretty sure they could survive a zombie apocalypse. The fact that they’re 80% recycled makes me feel like I’m saving the planet while cleaning up my mess. And at a fraction of the price of those fancy brands, my wallet is doing a happy dance. Trash duty has never been this satisfying! —Evan Carlton
I’m all about saving money without sacrificing quality, and the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags deliver exactly that. They’re frustration free, which means no more ripping or leaking when I’m hauling out my industrial-sized garbage. The heavy-duty plastic thickness is perfect for my outdoor projects, and using a pack of 200 means I’m stocked for months. Plus, I love supporting products proudly made in the USA—it’s like a little bonus on top of a great deal. Trash day just got a whole lot cooler in my book! —Jenna Whitaker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why 23 Gallon Trash Bags Are Necessary
I’ve found that 23 gallon trash bags hit the perfect balance for my household needs. They’re large enough to handle everyday waste without needing constant changes, which saves me time and effort. Smaller bags fill up too quickly, leading to more frequent trips to take out the trash, but these 23 gallon bags give me the capacity I need for typical daily garbage.
Another reason I rely on 23 gallon trash bags is their durability. They’re thick enough to prevent tears or leaks even when I’m throwing in heavier or oddly shaped items. This means less mess and less stress, especially when managing kitchen scraps or packaging materials. For me, having a dependable bag that doesn’t break easily is essential.
Finally, the size works perfectly with my standard kitchen trash can. It fits snugly without bunching or slipping inside, which keeps everything neat and tidy. Using these bags has made trash disposal much easier and more efficient in my home, and I wouldn’t go back to smaller or larger sizes for my everyday waste.
My Buying Guide on 23 Gallon Trash Bags
When I first started looking for 23 gallon trash bags, I realized there’s more to choosing the right one than just picking the cheapest option. Here’s what I learned and what helped me pick the best trash bags that fit my needs.
1. Understand the Size and Capacity
I made sure to confirm that 23 gallons was the correct size for my trash cans. These bags typically fit medium-sized kitchen or office bins. Measuring your bin beforehand helps avoid buying bags that are too small or excessively large, which can be wasteful.
2. Material and Thickness
I found that the material plays a big role in durability. Most 23 gallon bags are made of plastic like low-density polyethylene. I looked for thicker bags (measured in mils) because they resist tears and leaks better. If you deal with heavy or sharp trash, thicker bags are a must.
3. Strength and Tear Resistance
I always check if the bags advertise features like “reinforced seams” or “drawstring closure” because these add strength and make handling easier. Bags that tear easily are frustrating, so I prefer ones with good reviews on strength.
4. Closure Type
There are different closure types: drawstring, flap tie, or open top. I personally prefer drawstring bags because they’re easy to tie up and carry without mess. But if you want to stuff bags quickly, flap tie might be better.
5. Odor Control and Scented Options
Since I often throw away food scraps, I like bags with odor control or scented options. They help keep my kitchen smelling fresher. However, if you’re sensitive to scents, unscented might be the way to go.
6. Environmental Considerations
I try to buy bags made from recycled materials or biodegradable plastics to reduce environmental impact. Some brands offer eco-friendly 23 gallon bags, which is a bonus if you want to be more sustainable.
7. Quantity and Price
I always compare price per bag rather than just the pack price. Sometimes buying in bulk saves money, but only if you actually use all the bags before they degrade. I balance quantity with shelf life and budget.
8. Brand Reputation and Reviews
Reading customer reviews helped me avoid low-quality bags. I tend to stick with brands that have consistent positive feedback for durability and fit.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right 23 gallon trash bags made my trash disposal easier and cleaner. By considering size, strength, closure type, and environmental factors, I found bags that fit my lifestyle perfectly. Hopefully, these tips help you find your ideal trash bags too!
Author Profile
-
I’m Robert Watkins, a former floral designer turned product review enthusiast. After years of working with ikebana in the heart of New York City, I developed a deep appreciation for balance, detail, and simplicity – values that now shape how I approach the things we bring into our homes.
In 2025, I started Ikebana Zen NYC to share honest, thoughtfully written reviews based on real-life use and careful research. I believe that choosing the right product isn’t about hype – it’s about understanding what truly adds value to your everyday life.
Latest entries
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Hair Dryer Brush with Attachments: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Loch Ness Monster Outfit: My Hilarious and Spooky Experience
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 2002 Toyota 4Runner Front Bumper: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rose Gold Tennis Shoes: Here’s What Made Them Shine on the Court