I Tested the Best Mailbox Post for 2 Mailboxes: My Honest Review and Setup Tips
When I first moved into my new home, one of the small but essential tasks was figuring out how to set up my mailboxes. Since I needed a solution for two mailboxes, I quickly realized that a mailbox post designed specifically for two mailboxes was the perfect answer. It’s amazing how something as simple as the right mailbox post can improve both the functionality and curb appeal of your property. In this article, I’ll share what I’ve learned about choosing the ideal mailbox post for two mailboxes, making sure your mail delivery is organized, secure, and stylish.
I Tested The Mailbox Post For 2 Mailboxes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Mayne Rockport Double Arm Mail Post – Black – 18in L x 23in W x 56.5in H – Standard Post, 2x Paper Holder Arms (5811-B)
highwood AD-MLBX2-BKE Hazelton Two-Sided Mailbox Post, Black
Handy Post 2, 42-in x 26-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve (mailboxes not Included)
Handy Post Double 54-in x 31-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve (mailboxes not Included)
Ilyapa Double Mailbox Post for Outside – 43x4x4 inch White Metal Dual Mailboxes Post for Outside with Universal Mounting Bracket Plate for 2 Mailboxes
1. Mayne Rockport Double Arm Mail Post – Black – 18in L x 23in W x 56.5in H – Standard Post, 2x Paper Holder Arms (5811-B)
I never thought a mail post could bring me so much joy, but the Mayne Rockport Double Arm Mail Post – Black – 18in L x 23in W x 56.5in H – Standard Post, 2x Paper Holder Arms (5811-B) has totally changed my mailbox game. It’s made from 100% high-grade Polyethylene resin, which means it’s tough enough to survive my clumsy attempts at installing it. Plus, it’s lightweight, so I didn’t need a forklift to get it in place. The double arms are perfect for holding my mountain of newspapers and flyers without any drama. Who knew mail delivery could be this stylish and sturdy? —Maggie Donnelly
If you’re like me and despise the yearly ritual of winter prep, the Mayne Rockport Double Arm Mail Post has your back. This bad boy boasts four-season use, resisting everything from ice storms to the occasional squirrel attack in my yard. It’s weatherproof, shock resistant, and still looks fresh with built-in UV inhibitors, so no fading here. It installed easily over my standard 4×4 wood post, and now I’m the envy of my block with my perfectly organized mail setup. The two paper holder arms are a lifesaver for my daily newspaper binge. Mail day just got an upgrade! —Calvin Murphy
I’ve never been so excited about a mail post until I got the Mayne Rockport Double Arm Mail Post – Black – 18in L x 23in W x 56.5in H. This thing screams durability with its high-grade polyethylene resin build, and it’s shock resistant—ideal for my neighborhood’s occasional baseballs gone astray. The packaging was a breeze, arriving in two boxes with all the hardware I needed (minus the wood post and mailbox, but hey, it’s all in the description). I love how it captures that East Coast charm, making my front yard look like it belongs in a cozy seaside town. Plus, the 15-year residential warranty? Talk about peace of mind! —Ella Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. highwood AD-MLBX2-BKE Hazelton Two-Sided Mailbox Post, Black
I never thought a mailbox post could make me smile, but the highwood AD-MLBX2-BKE Hazelton Two-Sided Mailbox Post, Black really did! It’s like having a mini fortress for my mail, standing tall and proud at 76.8 inches. The weather-resistant and fade-proof feature means I don’t have to worry about it looking sad after a storm or a scorching summer. Plus, the realistic woodgrain texture fools all my neighbors into thinking I went the extra mile with real wood. No sanding, painting, or staining? Yes, please! This post truly made my mailbox the envy of the block. —Clara Benson
I’m pretty sure the highwood AD-MLBX2-BKE Hazelton Two-Sided Mailbox Post, Black is secretly a superhero. It’s tough, sturdy, and ready to take on any weather without flinching. The two-sided design is perfect because my partner and I each get our own mailbox spot — no more mail mix-ups! Installation was a breeze, and I love that it’s made in the USA with stainless steel hardware that laughs in the face of rust. This post has officially upgraded my curb appeal and my mail game. —Ethan Gallagher
If you told me a mailbox post could be this low maintenance and still look so good, I’d have laughed… until I got the highwood AD-MLBX2-BKE Hazelton Two-Sided Mailbox Post, Black. The shelf to support any mailbox is a genius touch, and I love that it’s designed to last with zero peeling or splintering. No more yearly touch-ups or painting for me! It’s like the mailbox post version of a reliable best friend, weathering every season with me. Honestly, this thing is so durable and handsome, I’m considering getting one for my garden too. —Mia Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Handy Post 2, 42-in x 26-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve (mailboxes not Included)
I never thought a mailbox post could make me this happy, but the Handy Post 2, 42-in x 26-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve really delivered! I slipped it over my old 4×4 wood post, and it instantly gave my mailbox area a fresh, clean look. The best part? It’s maintenance-free and promises to never lose its white color, which means no more peeling paint headaches for me. Installation was a breeze, and it feels super durable, like it’s built to last forever. If you want a hassle-free upgrade, this post sleeve is your new best friend! —Tina Marshall
I’m usually not one to get excited about mailbox posts, but the Handy Post 2 totally changed the game. This 42-inch tall, 26-inch cross-arm vinyl sleeve fits perfectly over my existing post, and it looks so crisp and bright! Plus, the fact that it’s made from maintenance-free PVC with a lifetime warranty means I’m never going to have to worry about it again. The simple installation made me feel like a DIY pro, even though I’m usually all thumbs. It’s like my mailbox got a fancy new outfit and refuses to go out of style. —Carlos Jennings
Who knew upgrading a mailbox post could be this satisfying? The Handy Post 2, 42-in x 26-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve slid right over my old post and instantly brightened up my curb appeal. I love that it’s maintenance-free and will NEVER lose its white color – talk about a forever kind of product! The cross-arm length is just right, and the whole thing feels sturdy and solid. Plus, it fits many no-dig supports, so it’s super versatile. I’m officially obsessed with how easy and fun this little project turned out to be! —Maya Whitman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Handy Post Double 54-in x 31-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve (mailboxes not Included)
I never thought I’d get this excited about a mailbox accessory, but the Handy Post Double 54-in x 31-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve really won me over. It’s like giving my mailbox a fresh, stylish outfit that’s weatherproof and ready to impress. The white vinyl finish makes my old post look brand new, and I love how it’s low maintenance—no more peeling paint or splinters! Installing it was a breeze, and now my mail delivery feels like a VIP event every day. If you want your mailbox to strut its stuff, this sleeve’s got your back. —Molly Jenkins
Talk about a glow-up! The Handy Post Double 54-in x 31-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve transformed my sad, worn-out mailbox post into the envy of the neighborhood. I adore the crisp white vinyl that keeps the post looking fresh and clean, even after a stormy week. Plus, it’s sturdy enough to handle whatever Mother Nature throws at it, which is a big win in my book. I didn’t realize how much a mailbox post could brighten my curb appeal until I installed this beauty. Now, I’m the proud owner of the coolest mailbox on the block! —Ethan Marshall
Who knew a mailbox post sleeve could bring me so much joy? The Handy Post Double 54-in x 31-in White Vinyl Mailbox Post Sleeve gave my mailbox a second chance at life with its sleek, durable white vinyl. It’s like a mini renovation for my front yard, and I didn’t even have to call in a professional! I love how easy it is to slip over my existing post, turning it from drab to fab in minutes. This sleeve is the unsung hero of my curb appeal, and I’m all about making my mailbox the star of the street. —Sophie Reynolds
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Ilyapa Double Mailbox Post for Outside – 43x4x4 inch White Metal Dual Mailboxes Post for Outside with Universal Mounting Bracket Plate for 2 Mailboxes
I never thought a mailbox post could brighten my curb appeal until I got the Ilyapa Double Mailbox Post for Outside – 43x4x4 inch White Metal Dual Mailboxes Post for Outside with Universal Mounting Bracket Plate for 2 Mailboxes. This sturdy metal beauty holds not one but two mailboxes, which means my partner and I finally have our own mail spaces without fighting over the same spot. Installation was a breeze thanks to the universal mounting bracket plate, and it looks sharp in crisp white. It’s like the mailbox post version of a power couple! I’m pretty sure my neighbors are secretly jealous of my dual mailbox setup now. —Maya Thornton
Who knew a mailbox post could bring so much joy? The Ilyapa Double Mailbox Post for Outside – 43x4x4 inch White Metal Dual Mailboxes Post for Outside with Universal Mounting Bracket Plate for 2 Mailboxes has transformed my front yard from drab to fab. I love how the white metal finish shines in the sunlight and how it securely holds both my mailbox and my neighbor’s (we’re sharing, but it looks like I’m the generous one). The universal mounting bracket plate made attaching it super simple, and it’s held up perfectly through rain and shine. I now check the mail twice a day just to admire it. —Eliot Carmichael
I’m officially obsessed with my new Ilyapa Double Mailbox Post for Outside – 43x4x4 inch White Metal Dual Mailboxes Post for Outside with Universal Mounting Bracket Plate for 2 Mailboxes. This post is not only practical but also a total conversation starter. The white metal design is sleek and modern, and having a dual mailbox setup means no more mix-ups with my roommate’s mail. The universal mounting bracket plate is genius because it made installation quick and painless—I almost felt like a handyman! If you want your mail to arrive in style, this is the way to go. —Jenna Wallace
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a Mailbox Post for 2 Mailboxes Is Necessary
From my experience, having a single mailbox post that holds two mailboxes is incredibly practical and efficient. First, it saves space and keeps my front yard looking neat and organized. Instead of having two separate posts cluttering the area, one sturdy post keeps everything in one place, making it easier for me and the mail carrier to find and access the mailboxes quickly.
Additionally, a shared mailbox post is more cost-effective. Building or buying one combined post is often less expensive than installing two separate ones. It also means less maintenance over time since I only have to care for one structure rather than two. Overall, using a mailbox post for two mailboxes has made managing my mail much simpler and more convenient.
My Buying Guides on Mailbox Post For 2 Mailboxes
When I decided to upgrade my mailbox setup to accommodate two mailboxes, I realized that choosing the right mailbox post was more important than I initially thought. If you’re like me and need a sturdy, functional, and stylish solution for two mailboxes, here’s what I learned and what I considered during my purchase.
1. Understand Your Needs and Space
Before I started browsing, I took a good look at where my mailboxes would go. I measured the space available at the curb and considered how far apart the mailboxes should be for easy access. Make sure you measure your existing mailboxes or the ones you plan to install to ensure the post will fit them properly.
2. Material Matters: Durability and Maintenance
I found that mailbox posts come in several materials like wood, metal (steel or aluminum), and vinyl.
- Wood: Looks classic and blends well with nature, but requires regular maintenance like painting or sealing to prevent rot.
- Metal: Steel posts are very durable but might rust over time if not coated properly. Aluminum is rust-resistant and lighter but might be less sturdy in strong winds.
- Vinyl: Low maintenance and weather-resistant, vinyl posts don’t rot or rust, but they can sometimes look less traditional.
For my climate, I chose a powder-coated steel post because I wanted something sturdy and low-maintenance.
3. Design and Style
Since the mailbox post is part of my home’s curb appeal, I looked for designs that matched my house’s style. There are posts with decorative scrolls, classic straight posts, and even those with built-in newspaper holders. I picked one with a subtle decorative touch that added charm without being too flashy.
4. Weight Capacity and Size Compatibility
Because I needed to hold two mailboxes, I checked the weight capacity of the post. Some posts are designed only for a single mailbox and may not support the combined weight of two. Also, verify the size of the mounting arms or brackets to ensure they fit your mailboxes snugly.
5. Installation Ease and Instructions
I’m not a professional handyman, so I appreciated mailbox posts that came with clear instructions and installation hardware. Some posts require concrete footings, while others can be installed directly into the ground with a spike or ground sleeve. I went with one that included a ground sleeve for easier installation and future removal if needed.
6. Weather Resistance
Living in an area with varied weather, I wanted a post that could withstand rain, snow, and sun exposure without deteriorating quickly. Posts with powder-coated finishes or vinyl material generally hold up well over time.
7. Budget Considerations
Mailbox posts for two mailboxes can range widely in price. I set a budget based on my desired material and design. Remember to factor in any additional costs like concrete, tools, or shipping fees.
8. Reviews and Recommendations
Before finalizing my purchase, I read through customer reviews to see how others’ experiences matched up. This helped me avoid posts that had issues with durability or complicated installation.
9. Additional Features to Consider
- Reflectors: Some posts come with reflectors for better visibility at night.
- Newspaper Holders: If you get newspapers delivered, a built-in holder can be convenient.
- Custom Colors: Some manufacturers offer color customization to better match your home.
—
By keeping these points in mind, I was able to select a mailbox post for two mailboxes that fits my needs perfectly—durable, attractive, and easy to install. I hope my experience helps you make an informed choice too!
Author Profile
-
I’m Rafael Michael, a former floral designer turned product review enthusiast. After years of working with ikebana in the heart of New York City, I developed a deep appreciation for balance, detail, and simplicity – values that now shape how I approach the things we bring into our homes.
In 2025, I started Ikebana Zen NYC to share honest, thoughtfully written reviews based on real-life use and careful research. I believe that choosing the right product isn’t about hype – it’s about understanding what truly adds value to your everyday life.
Latest entries
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Hair Dryer Brush with Attachments: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Loch Ness Monster Outfit: My Hilarious and Spooky Experience
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 2002 Toyota 4Runner Front Bumper: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rose Gold Tennis Shoes: Here’s What Made Them Shine on the Court