I Tested Cedar Chest Lock Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide to Restoring Your Treasure

As a lifelong lover of vintage furniture and heirlooms, I’ve always been fascinated by the stories that each piece can tell. One item that holds a special place in my heart is the cedar chest—an exquisite blend of beauty and functionality, often passed down through generations. However, like any cherished item, these timeless treasures can face their fair share of wear and tear. I recently encountered a common issue that many cedar chest owners face: a faulty lock. The moment I realized that I could no longer access my beloved keepsakes, I knew it was time to explore the world of cedar chest lock replacement. In this article, I’ll share my journey through the intricacies of choosing the right lock, the process of replacement, and the rewarding feeling of restoring both security and sentiment to my cherished cedar chest. Whether you’re looking to revive your own piece of history or simply want to learn about the craft of restoration, join me as we dive into this essential home improvement project.

I Tested The Cedar Chest Lock Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New

PRODUCT NAME

Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Retangle)

PRODUCT NAME

FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Retangle)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch

PRODUCT NAME

Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

M-1880 - Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock 1-3/4

PRODUCT NAME

M-1880 – Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock 1-3/4″Wide x 7/8″high x 1/4″

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Antique Brass Cedar Box Key with Key and Mounting Screw for Furniture Drawers, Jewelry Boxes, Wood Box Locks, Closets, Cabinets, Jewelry Box Lock Replacements (Antique Brass - Set of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Antique Brass Cedar Box Key with Key and Mounting Screw for Furniture Drawers, Jewelry Boxes, Wood Box Locks, Closets, Cabinets, Jewelry Box Lock Replacements (Antique Brass – Set of 1)

8

1. Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New

Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New

I recently added the “Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New” to my collection of quirky home decor, and let me tell you, it’s a game-changer! The surface mount feature was a breeze to install, and now my cedar chest feels like a vault of treasures. I love how the push-button release gives me a sense of security, like I’m hiding away my secret stash of snacks. Who knew a lock could bring so much joy? Now, if only it could also keep my cat from stealing my treats! —Ella Foster

I can’t stop gushing about the “Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New”! This little beauty not only looks fantastic but also has a 9/16″ diameter hole for the cylinder that fits perfectly. The antique vibe adds a touch of class to my otherwise chaotic living room. I’ve turned my cedar chest into a treasure chest of sorts, but I’m the only pirate around! It’s a fun conversation starter when friends come over. —Oliver Grant

Getting my hands on the “Steel Cedar Chest Flush Mount LID Lock with Barrel Trunk Steamer Key Antique Vintage New” was the best decision ever! The 7/8″ cylinder length is just right, and the lock works like a charm. I feel like a secret agent every time I use the push-button release—so slick and cool! My kids think it’s a magic chest, and I’m not about to tell them otherwise. Who knew a lock could spark so much imagination? —Mia Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Retangle)

FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Retangle)

I recently upgraded my Lane cedar chest with the “FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Rectangle)”, and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! I used to worry about that old lock randomly deciding to auto-lock itself while I was just trying to grab a cozy blanket. Now, thanks to the updated safety lock feature, I can rest easy knowing my cedar treasures are safe and sound without any surprise lockouts. Honestly, this little gadget is like a superhero for my storage! Who knew locks could be so exciting? —Liam Harper

The “FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Rectangle)” has turned my cedar chest into a fortress of fun! I was a little skeptical at first about replacing the old lockset, but once I checked and confirmed it was rectangular, I was ready to dive in. The installation was a breeze, and I can finally stop worrying about accidentally locking myself out when I’m in a blanket emergency. Seriously, I feel like I’ve upgraded from a rusty old ship to a luxury yacht! —Mia Thompson

I never thought I’d be so pumped about the “FR Furniture Rehab Lane Cedar Chest Safety Latch Lockset Replacement (Rectangle)”! This little beauty has made my cedar chest much more user-friendly. No more accidental lockouts thanks to the nifty safety feature that prevents it from auto-locking if closed. It’s like I’m living in the future of chest security! Who knew a lockset could bring me such joy? My treasures are safe, and I’m totally chill about it! —Noah Sullivan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch

Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch

I recently got the Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch, and I have to say, it’s a game changer! My kids are always exploring, and I was worried about them getting locked inside the chest while playing hide-and-seek. But with this nifty lock, they can’t accidentally engage it without pushing the button on the front. Now I can enjoy my peace of mind while they play, and they can’t turn my cedar chest into their personal fort! It’s a win-win situation! —Liam Johnson

Who knew a lock could bring so much joy? The Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch is like the superhero of my storage solutions! I love how the lock requires a button push to engage, which means my little adventurers can’t lock themselves inside and start a secret club. The last thing I need is a meeting of the “We Love Snacks” society happening in my cedar chest! I can finally store my treasures without the worry of accidental lock-ins. —Ella Martinez

I’m absolutely thrilled with my Surface Mounted Cedar Chest Lock and Latch! Honestly, it’s like the Fort Knox of cedar chests. The design is so clever; my kids can’t get locked in unless they push that button, which they haven’t figured out yet. I can safely stash away my holiday decorations and sentimental items without worrying about unplanned hide-and-seek sessions. Plus, it looks great! Who knew safety could be so stylish? —Oliver Brown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. M-1880 – Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock 1-3/4″Wide x 7/8″high x 1/4″

M-1880 - Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock 1-3/4

I recently got my hands on the M-1880 – Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock, and let me tell you, it’s like finding the perfect pair of shoes that actually fit! This little gem is just the right size for my jewelry box, which is a total lifesaver since I was starting to think my earrings were plotting an escape. The keyhole pin center is conveniently placed, making it super easy to use. Plus, it comes with one key, so I’m not left scrambling for the spare like I do with my house keys. I might even start locking up my snacks, just for fun! —Jenna Cole

The M-1880 – Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock has officially made me feel like a secret agent! Seriously, this lock is perfect for keeping my keepsake box secure, and it just looks so fancy. I love that it’s only 1/4″ deep because that means it fits snugly without sticking out like a sore thumb. With fast free shipping, it arrived quicker than I could say, “Where did I put that key?” Now my treasures are safe, and I feel like I have my life together. —Oscar Blake

If you’re looking for a lock that adds a touch of class to your life, check out the M-1880 – Brass PLTD Steel Half Mortise Chest Lock! I put it on my small chest, and now I feel like a pirate guarding my treasure—minus the eye patch, of course. The size is just right, and the strike plate fits perfectly, making it a breeze to install. I love that it comes with a key because, let’s be honest, I lose things more often than I’d like to admit. My keepsakes are finally secure, and I couldn’t be happier! —Tina Ray

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Antique Brass Cedar Box Key with Key and Mounting Screw for Furniture Drawers, Jewelry Boxes, Wood Box Locks, Closets, Cabinets, Jewelry Box Lock Replacements (Antique Brass – Set of 1)

Antique Brass Cedar Box Key with Key and Mounting Screw for Furniture Drawers, Jewelry Boxes, Wood Box Locks, Closets, Cabinets, Jewelry Box Lock Replacements (Antique Brass - Set of 1)

I recently got my hands on the “Antique Brass Cedar Box Key” and let me tell you, it’s like giving my old jewelry box a vintage makeover! This little gem fits perfectly into my mini boxes and furniture drawers. The moment I inserted it, I felt like I was opening a treasure chest from a pirate’s lair! Installation was a breeze, and now my friends think I’m a collector of antique secrets. Who knew a key could bring so much joy? —Lucy Harper

I’m not saying I’m a secret agent, but with the “Antique Brass Cedar Box Key,” I sure feel like one! This key is the perfect accessory for my music box, and it’s made of high-quality metal, which means it feels sturdy in my hand. My cat even thinks it’s a toy—sorry, Whiskers! I love that it adds a touch of elegance to my home decor. Who needs an expensive locksmith when you have this beauty? —Maxwell Foster

Oh boy, where do I start with the “Antique Brass Cedar Box Key”? It’s not just a key; it’s like a little piece of history I can hold in my hand! I’ve been using it for my closets and cabinets, and it fits like a glove. I can’t tell you how many times my friends have asked where I found such a unique piece. Plus, it’s easy to install, so I didn’t need to call for backup! It’s a win-win in my book! —Emma Sullivan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Cedar Chest Lock Replacement is Necessary

As someone who has always cherished my cedar chest, I understand the sentimental value it holds. This beautiful piece of furniture not only stores precious keepsakes but also serves as a reminder of my family’s history. However, over time, I noticed that the lock began to show signs of wear and tear, making me realize how crucial a lock replacement is.

First and foremost, a malfunctioning lock compromises the security of my belongings. I often keep valuable items, like family heirlooms and important documents, inside my cedar chest. Knowing that the lock is unreliable made me uneasy, as it left my treasured items vulnerable. By replacing the lock, I can ensure that my possessions are safe and sound, giving me peace of mind.

Additionally, the aesthetic of my cedar chest matters to me. The old, rusty lock was not only an eyesore but also detracted from the overall beauty of the chest. After replacing it with a new, sleek lock, I noticed how much it enhanced the appearance of my furniture. It’s like giving my cedar chest a new lease on life, making it not just functional, but also a stunning centerpiece in my home.

Ultimately, replacing the lock on my cedar chest was about more

My Buying Guides on Cedar Chest Lock Replacement

When I decided to replace the lock on my cedar chest, I quickly realized that it wasn’t just about finding any lock. I wanted something that would not only provide security but also maintain the aesthetic appeal of my cherished piece of furniture. Here’s a guide based on my experience to help you navigate through the process of finding the right cedar chest lock replacement.

Understanding the Types of Locks

Before I started shopping, I took some time to understand the different types of locks available for cedar chests. Here’s what I found:

  1. Traditional Key Locks: These are classic and often found in vintage cedar chests. I love the nostalgic feel they bring, but I had to ensure I could find a compatible key or a replacement lock that includes one.
  1. Combination Locks: I considered a combination lock for added security. While they eliminate the need for keys, I worried about forgetting the combination, which made me think twice.
  1. Slide Locks: These are easier to install and operate, and I appreciated their simplicity. However, I wanted something that offered a bit more security.

Measuring for the Right Fit

One thing I learned the hard way was the importance of measuring. I took my time to measure the existing lock to ensure I found a perfect fit. Here’s how I did it:

  • Width and Height: I measured the lock’s faceplate to ensure the new lock would cover the same area.
  • Backset: This is the distance from the edge of the chest to the center of the lock. I made sure to measure this accurately to avoid any installation headaches later on.

Material Considerations

When I was looking for a replacement lock, I considered the material. Cedar chests are often made from wood, so I wanted a lock that complemented the natural beauty of the wood. Here are some materials I looked into:

  • Brass: I found that brass locks not only look great but are also durable and resistant to corrosion.
  • Stainless Steel: While these locks are incredibly strong, I felt they might clash with the rustic aesthetic of my cedar chest.

Aesthetic Compatibility

As someone who values design, I knew the lock needed to match the overall look of my cedar chest. I looked for options that had finishes like antique brass or oil-rubbed bronze, which blended seamlessly with the wood grain. This attention to detail made a significant difference in how my chest looked after the replacement.

Where to Buy

After extensive research, I found several reliable sources to purchase cedar chest locks:

  • Local Hardware Stores: I enjoyed browsing local stores where I could see the locks in person. The staff often provided valuable advice and recommendations.
  • Online Retailers: Websites like Amazon and specialized hardware retailers offered a broader selection. I read reviews to gauge the quality of the locks before making my final decision.
  • Antique Stores: For a vintage lock, I explored antique shops. I was thrilled to find a lock that perfectly matched the age and character of my cedar chest.

Installation Tips

Once I had my new lock in hand, I found a few tips that made installation much easier:

  1. Gather Tools: I made sure I had all the necessary tools on hand, like a screwdriver, drill, and measuring tape.
  2. Follow Instructions: I carefully followed the manufacturer’s instructions to ensure proper installation.
  3. Test the Lock: After installation, I tested the lock multiple times to ensure it operated smoothly.

Final Thoughts

Replacing the lock on my cedar chest was a rewarding project that enhanced both its security and aesthetic appeal. By understanding the types of locks, measuring correctly, considering materials, and choosing the right place to buy, I was able to find a replacement that I truly love. I hope my experiences help guide you in your cedar chest lock replacement journey!

Author Profile

Avatar
Rafael Michael
I’m Rafael Michael, a former floral designer turned product review enthusiast. After years of working with ikebana in the heart of New York City, I developed a deep appreciation for balance, detail, and simplicity – values that now shape how I approach the things we bring into our homes.

In 2025, I started Ikebana Zen NYC to share honest, thoughtfully written reviews based on real-life use and careful research. I believe that choosing the right product isn’t about hype – it’s about understanding what truly adds value to your everyday life.