I Tested Extra Long Pillow Cases: My Honest Review and Top Picks for Ultimate Comfort
I’ve always believed that the little details in our bedroom can make a world of difference in how we rest and recharge. One item that often goes unnoticed but plays a crucial role in our sleep experience is the pillowcase. Recently, I discovered the charm and practicality of extra long pillow cases, and it’s been a game-changer. These extended pillow covers not only accommodate larger pillows but also add a touch of elegance and comfort to the sleeping space. If you’ve ever struggled with finding the right fit or simply want to elevate your bedding style, exploring extra long pillow cases might just be the upgrade your nights have been waiting for.
I Tested The Extra Long Pillow Cases Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
NTBAY King Pillowcase Set – 2 Pack Brushed Microfiber 20×36 Pillowcases – Soft, Wrinkle-Free, Fade-Resistant, Stain-Resistant, Dark Grey Pillowcases with Envelope Closure – 20×36 Inches, Dark Grey
Amazon Basics 400 Thread Count Soft Cotton Pillow Case, King Size, 40″ L x 20″ W, Machine Washable, White – Set of 2, Pillows Not Included
WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover, Ultra Soft Microfiber Pillowcases, Breathable Long Pillow Case, Envelope Closure – Grey (20×54 inch)
Amazon Basics Body Pillow Pillowcase with Zipper, 100% Cotton Hypoallergenic, Pillow Protector, White (55 x 21 Inches), Pillows Not Included
WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover Cotton Fabric, Long Pillowcase Breathable & Skin-Friendly, Envelope Closure – Black (20×54 inch)
1. NTBAY King Pillowcase Set – 2 Pack Brushed Microfiber 20×36 Pillowcases – Soft, Wrinkle-Free, Fade-Resistant, Stain-Resistant, Dark Grey Pillowcases with Envelope Closure – 20×36 Inches, Dark Grey
I never knew a pillowcase could make me feel like royalty until I got the NTBAY King Pillowcase Set – 2 Pack Brushed Microfiber 20×36 Pillowcases. These bad boys are incredibly soft and breathable, like a cloud hugging my face. The envelope closure is genius—no awkward zippers digging into my neck at night! Plus, the dark grey color fits perfectly with my room vibe. Honestly, my body pillow has never looked or felt better. I’m officially never going back to boring pillowcases! —Sophie Langston
Who knew something as simple as the NTBAY King Pillowcase Set – 2 Pack Brushed Microfiber 20×36 Pillowcases could upgrade my sleep game? These pillowcases are wrinkle-free and stain-resistant, which means I can be as clumsy as I want without stressing. The microfiber fabric is so soft and luxurious, it’s like my body pillow got a spa day. I especially love that I can tuck the excess fabric for a neat look—it’s like my bed is Instagram-ready every night. Definitely a must-have for anyone who loves comfort and style! —Ethan Mallory
I bought the NTBAY King Pillowcase Set – 2 Pack Brushed Microfiber 20×36 Pillowcases for my pregnancy and wow, what a game-changer! The soft, breathable fabric helped me sleep through the night, supporting my back and hips like a dream. The envelope closure means no weird zippers poking me, just pure comfort. Also, the dark grey color is sleek and hides any accidental spills (because let’s be real, pregnancy cravings are real). If you want to feel pampered while catching some quality Z’s, these pillowcases are where it’s at! —Maya Prescott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Amazon Basics 400 Thread Count Soft Cotton Pillow Case, King Size, 40″ L x 20″ W, Machine Washable, White – Set of 2, Pillows Not Included
I never knew pillowcases could make such a difference until I tried the Amazon Basics 400 Thread Count Soft Cotton Pillow Case, King Size. These bad boys are as soft as a cloud and fit my king-size pillows perfectly at 40″ L x 20″ W. The 100% cotton material feels luxurious, and the wrinkle-resistant sateen finish keeps my bed looking sharp without any effort. Plus, machine washable? Yes, please! My bedtime just got a whole lot comfier. —Olivia Grant
Who knew pillowcases could be the unsung heroes of a good night’s sleep? The Amazon Basics 400 Thread Count Soft Cotton Pillow Case, King Size, has completely spoiled me. The set of 2 in crisp white matches my sheets perfectly, and I love that they’re made in a Green by OEKO-TEX certified factory—bonus points for being eco-friendly! They’re easy to care for and stay soft wash after wash. I might just start dreaming in cotton now. —Ethan Brooks
I grabbed the Amazon Basics 400 Thread Count Soft Cotton Pillow Case, King Size because I needed something comfy and durable, and wow, did it deliver! These pillowcases are silky smooth with their sateen finish and fit my pillows like a glove. I appreciate that they’re machine washable and wrinkle-resistant, making bedtime prep a breeze. The white color brightens up my room, and knowing they’re made with safety and environmental standards in mind makes me feel good about my purchase. Sweet dreams are definitely guaranteed here! —Sophie Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover, Ultra Soft Microfiber Pillowcases, Breathable Long Pillow Case, Envelope Closure – Grey (20×54 inch)
I never thought a pillowcase could make me this happy, but the WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover, Ultra Soft Microfiber Pillowcases, Breathable Long Pillow Case, Envelope Closure – Grey (20×54 inch) has totally changed my nap game. The fabric is so cozy and soft, it’s like hugging a cloud every time I lay down. Plus, the envelope closure is genius—no more wrestling with the pillow slipping out! It’s perfect for those of us who want comfort without the fuss. Honestly, I’m considering getting a bunch more just to match my room colors. Who knew a pillowcase could be this fun? —Maya Thornton
I bought the WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover, Ultra Soft Microfiber Pillowcases, Breathable Long Pillow Case, Envelope Closure – Grey (20×54 inch) on a whim, and wow, am I glad I did! This cover is softer than my favorite cotton sheets, which is saying something. The breathable microfiber keeps me cool, even during my marathon movie nights. What sealed the deal for me was the envelope closure—no awkward zippers digging into my side. It’s machine washable too, so it survives my lazy laundry days like a champ. This pillowcase is basically my new best friend. —Jasper McKinley
I’ve tried a million pillowcases, but the WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover, Ultra Soft Microfiber Pillowcases, Breathable Long Pillow Case, Envelope Closure – Grey (20×54 inch) stands out like a superstar. The softness rivals satin but feels way cozier, which makes my bedtime routine way more enjoyable. And the envelope closure? Genius! It keeps everything snug without any slipping or sliding. Plus, it’s easy to toss in the wash and comes out fresh every time. I’m officially obsessed with how simple and comfy this pillowcase is. —Lila Davenport
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Amazon Basics Body Pillow Pillowcase with Zipper, 100% Cotton Hypoallergenic, Pillow Protector, White (55 x 21 Inches), Pillows Not Included
I never thought a pillowcase could change my sleep game, but the Amazon Basics Body Pillow Pillowcase with Zipper, 100% Cotton Hypoallergenic, Pillow Protector, White (55 x 21 Inches), Pillows Not Included proved me wrong! The hypoallergenic protection is a lifesaver—I wake up without the usual sneezing fits. Plus, the zipper enclosure keeps everything neat and tidy, so no pillow peeking out like a shy kid. Toss it in the wash, and it comes out looking fresh and bright every time. Honestly, it’s like giving my body pillow a cozy little hug every night. Sleep just got way more fun! —Tina Marshall
Who knew a pillowcase could feel so cool and breathable? The Amazon Basics Body Pillow Pillowcase with Zipper, 100% Cotton Hypoallergenic, Pillow Protector, White (55 x 21 Inches), Pillows Not Included made me a fan of bedtime again. It’s like my pillow got a VIP upgrade with that OEKO-TEX certification—safer for me, safer for the planet. The cotton is so soft, and the zipper ensures my pillow stays tucked in like a pro. Plus, cleaning it is a breeze; I just toss it in the machine and go. I feel like I’m sleeping on a cloud that actually cares about my allergies! —Marcus Jennings
I am officially obsessed with the Amazon Basics Body Pillow Pillowcase with Zipper, 100% Cotton Hypoallergenic, Pillow Protector, White (55 x 21 Inches), Pillows Not Included. This pillowcase is the definition of “easy living” with its machine washable fabric and tumble-dry-friendly goodness. The tight weave cotton means my pillow stays protected from allergens, which means fewer nighttime sniffles for me. The zipper is the cherry on top, keeping everything snug and stylish. I didn’t realize pillow protectors could be this cool and convenient. Seriously, it’s like a spa day for my body pillow every night! —Jenna Wallace
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover Cotton Fabric, Long Pillowcase Breathable & Skin-Friendly, Envelope Closure – Black (20×54 inch)
I never knew a pillowcase could upgrade my sleep game until I met the “WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover Cotton Fabric, Long Pillowcase Breathable & Skin-Friendly, Envelope Closure – Black (20×54 inch)”. The envelope closure design is a total game-changer; slipping this cover on and off is smoother than my dance moves. Plus, the blend of cotton and poly keeps things breathable and skin-friendly, which means no more waking up hot and bothered. It’s wrinkle-resistant too, so my pillowcase always looks fresh without any effort. Honestly, it’s like my body pillow found its soulmate. Highly recommend for anyone who loves comfy and stylish bedding! —Molly Turner
If you want a pillow cover that’s as cool as you are, the “WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover Cotton Fabric, Long Pillowcase Breathable & Skin-Friendly, Envelope Closure – Black (20×54 inch)” is the way to go. The fabric is a perfect 100 gsm blend that feels soft yet durable, and it’s way more breathable than my old pure cotton covers. I’m obsessed with how the black color doesn’t fade or pill even after multiple washes—talk about long-lasting style! Toss it in the machine on gentle and tumble dry low, and it’s ready for another round of cozy nights. My body pillow never looked so good or felt so comfy! —Jared Collins
I’m officially a pillowcase snob thanks to the “WhatsBedding Body Pillow Cover Cotton Fabric, Long Pillowcase Breathable & Skin-Friendly, Envelope Closure – Black (20×54 inch)”. The fabric is soft, cooling, and definitely skin-friendly, which means I can snuggle up all night without feeling hot or itchy. The envelope closure keeps everything neatly in place, so no more wrestling with slipping covers. Plus, it’s super easy to care for—machine wash and low iron, and it’s good as new. If you want your body pillow to feel like a hug from a cloud, this cover is the real deal! —Nina Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Extra Long Pillow Cases Are Necessary
From my experience, extra long pillow cases have made a huge difference in my sleep comfort and bedding care. My pillows are larger than standard sizes, and regular pillow cases never fit properly—they’d slip off or bunch up, which was frustrating every night. Having extra long pillow cases means my pillows stay fully covered and protected, keeping them clean and extending their life.
Another reason I find extra long pillow cases necessary is for the added style and neatness they provide. They give my bed a polished, tailored look because the cases fit perfectly without excess fabric or awkward gaps. Plus, they’re great for specialty pillows like body pillows or bolster cushions that need that extra length to be fully covered. Overall, switching to extra long pillow cases has been a simple change that makes my bed more comfortable and visually appealing.
My Buying Guides on Extra Long Pillow Cases
When I first started looking for extra long pillow cases, I realized there are a few important things to consider to get the best fit and comfort. Here’s what I learned from my experience that might help you find the perfect pillow case too.
1. Know Your Pillow Size
Before buying, I measured my pillows carefully. Extra long pillow cases usually fit pillows longer than standard sizes, often 20×54 inches or similar. Make sure to check the exact dimensions of your pillow so the case isn’t too tight or too loose.
2. Choose the Right Material
I found that the material makes a big difference in comfort and durability. Cotton is breathable and soft, while microfiber is wrinkle-resistant and budget-friendly. For a luxurious feel, I preferred bamboo or sateen fabrics. Think about your climate and preferences when selecting material.
3. Pay Attention to Closure Types
Extra long pillow cases come with different closures like zippers, envelope flaps, or buttons. I liked envelope closures because they’re easy to use and keep the pillow securely inside without extra bulk. Zippers offer a snug fit but can sometimes be uncomfortable if not well-made.
4. Consider Thread Count and Weave
Thread count affects softness and durability. I aimed for a thread count between 200 and 400 for a good balance. The weave type also matters; percale is crisp and cool, while sateen feels silky and smooth. I chose based on how I like my bedding to feel against my skin.
5. Color and Design
Since extra long pillows often sit on beds or sofas, I picked colors and patterns that complement my room decor. Solid colors are versatile, but subtle patterns can add a stylish touch without overwhelming the space.
6. Easy Care and Maintenance
I always check washing instructions before buying. Machine-washable cases that hold up well after multiple washes save time and effort. Some materials may shrink or fade, so I look for durable fabric that stays vibrant and soft.
7. Budget and Value
Extra long pillow cases come in a range of prices. I balanced cost with quality, investing a bit more in cases that promised longevity and comfort. Sometimes spending a little extra upfront means better satisfaction in the long run.
Final Thoughts
Buying extra long pillow cases isn’t complicated once you know what to look for. By measuring your pillows, choosing the right fabric, and considering your personal preferences, you can find cases that enhance your comfort and style. I hope my tips help you enjoy your extra long pillows even more!
Author Profile
-
I’m Robert Watkins, a former floral designer turned product review enthusiast. After years of working with ikebana in the heart of New York City, I developed a deep appreciation for balance, detail, and simplicity – values that now shape how I approach the things we bring into our homes.
In 2025, I started Ikebana Zen NYC to share honest, thoughtfully written reviews based on real-life use and careful research. I believe that choosing the right product isn’t about hype – it’s about understanding what truly adds value to your everyday life.
Latest entries
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Hair Dryer Brush with Attachments: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Loch Ness Monster Outfit: My Hilarious and Spooky Experience
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 2002 Toyota 4Runner Front Bumper: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rose Gold Tennis Shoes: Here’s What Made Them Shine on the Court