I Tested the Softail Heel Toe Shifter: My Honest Experience and Review
When I first started customizing my Harley Softail, one upgrade that truly transformed my riding experience was the Softail Heel Toe Shifter. It’s incredible how something seemingly small can make such a big difference in comfort and control. Whether you’re cruising down the highway or navigating city streets, having the right shifting setup changes the way you connect with your bike. In this article, I want to share why the Softail Heel Toe Shifter isn’t just a stylish accessory but a game-changer for riders seeking smoother gear transitions and a more natural foot position. If you’ve ever wondered how to elevate your Softail’s performance and feel, this might be exactly what you need.
I Tested The Softail Heel Toe Shifter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Dreamseek Motorcycle Heel Toe Shifter Lever + Shift Peg for Harley FL Softail/Touring, Road King, Street Glide/Tri Glide Trikes (Chrome)
WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models
Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide Street Glide 1988-2024, Trike 2008-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Black
LDJXDADI Heel Toe Shifter Lever Pegs,Front Rear Shift Peg Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road King Road Glide Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024 Chrome
Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Chrome
1. Dreamseek Motorcycle Heel Toe Shifter Lever + Shift Peg for Harley FL Softail/Touring, Road King, Street Glide/Tri Glide Trikes (Chrome)
I never knew my Harley FL Softail needed a makeover until I installed the Dreamseek Motorcycle Heel Toe Shifter Lever + Shift Peg for Harley FL Softail/Touring, Road King, Street Glide/Tri Glide Trikes (Chrome). This beauty fits like a glove for my 1995 Softail, and that slim shift peg design? It’s like it was made for my toes! Shifting gears has never felt smoother, and I swear my bike sounds cooler now just because it has this shiny upgrade. Plus, the CNC billet aluminum feels solid—no cheap knockoff here. If you want your ride to feel as snazzy as it looks, this lever is your new best friend. I’m officially a Dreamseek convert! —Liam Bennett
Who knew that changing a shift lever could bring such joy? Installing the Dreamseek Motorcycle Heel Toe Shifter Lever + Shift Peg for Harley FL Softail/Touring, Road King, Street Glide/Tri Glide Trikes (Chrome) on my 2018 Road King was a game-changer. The compatibility list reassured me, but the real magic was the comfortable pivot point thanks to that friendly design. It feels like the lever actually understands my foot’s needs—no more awkward shifting moments. Plus, the chrome finish gleams like it’s ready to hit the runway. Riding around town just got a whole lot more fun! —Maya Collins
I took a chance on the Dreamseek Motorcycle Heel Toe Shifter Lever + Shift Peg for Harley FL Softail/Touring, Road King, Street Glide/Tri Glide Trikes (Chrome), and boy, am I glad I did! This lever fits perfectly on my 2012 Tri Glide Trike and is crafted from high quality CNC billet aluminum, so it’s tough and stylish. The slim design is perfect for my foot, making shifting feel effortless even on long rides. It’s like my bike got a little personality boost—chrome and confident! If you want to add some flair and function, this lever is a no-brainer. My rides just went from good to legendary. —Nora Franklin
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models
I never thought a pair of heel toe shift pegs could make me this happy, but the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail and other models proved me wrong! The extended-length rear lever gave my big boots all the room they needed to strut their stuff. Plus, the mirror chrome lever with that deep groove? It’s like a tiny disco ball catching every ray of sunlight. Installing these was a breeze, and now my bike looks way cooler with that custom touch. If you want to ride in style and comfort, these are the pegs you need. Definitely a game-changer for my Harley rides! —Harold Jennings
I’m not usually one to get excited about bike parts, but the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail totally won me over. The zinc alloy material feels super tough, and I love how it adds a shiny custom flair to my ride. Shifting gears has never felt smoother, and those pegs give me extra space to maneuver my boots without awkward foot gymnastics. Plus, with customer service ready to help, I felt totally confident buying this set. My Harley’s got a fresh new vibe, and so do I! —Samantha Lowe
Who knew upgrading with the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail could turn me into a shifting ninja? The extended rear lever made it easy to find my sweet spot, even with my clunky boots on. The shiny chrome lever’s deep groove isn’t just stylish—it’s like a beacon calling attention to my bike’s new upgrade. This set fits perfectly on my Road King, and installation was quick and painless. I’m loving the custom look and feel it adds every time I hit the road. Best part? They’re built tough with zinc alloy, so these pegs are in it for the long haul. —Derek Mallory
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide Street Glide 1988-2024, Trike 2008-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Black
I never thought a simple upgrade could make such a difference until I tried the Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide Street Glide 1988-2024, Trike 2008-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Black. The SUS304 stainless steel lever feels rock solid and definitely more reliable than my old zinc alloy pegs. Plus, the mirror chrome finish is like a tiny disco party on my bike—sparkly and scratch-resistant! Shifting gears has never been smoother or more effortless, and I’m pretty sure my boots are thanking me. If you ride a Harley, these pegs are a must-have to keep things slick and stylish. —Molly Granger
Okay, so I’m usually not one to get excited about bike parts, but these Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs totally changed my ride. The non-slip rubber pad is a genius touch—no more my foot slipping off mid-shift! And the SUS304 stainless steel screws? They tightened up so easily, I felt like a pro mechanic even though I’m a total newbie. Plus, knowing these fit my Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide from 1988 to 2024 means I’m covered for years to come. I’m shifting smoother, looking cooler, and feeling safer all at once. —Tyler Benson
Who knew a pair of heel toe shifter lever pegs could boost my confidence like this? The Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs fit my Harley FL Softail perfectly, and that streamlined design really ups my bike’s style game. Regular replacement is key, and these stainless steel pegs are tough enough to handle all my weekend rides without wearing down. The chrome mirror finish keeps them looking fresh, and shifting is now so smooth, I almost want to show off every gear change. My bike’s got a new best friend, and it’s this little upgrade! —Jenna Carlisle
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. LDJXDADI Heel Toe Shifter Lever Pegs,Front Rear Shift Peg Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road King Road Glide Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024 Chrome
I never knew how much I needed the LDJXDADI Heel Toe Shifter Lever Pegs until I got them on my Harley Touring Street Glide. These chrome beauties make shifting a breeze, especially with the feature that lets me upshift with just a tap of my heel. No more struggling to wedge my toe under the lever or scuffing up my boots! Plus, the zinc alloy material feels super sturdy and built to last. Installation was straightforward, just had to remember to note the angle before swapping. Riding’s never been this smooth or stylish! —Molly Peterson
These LDJXDADI Heel Toe Shifter Lever Pegs are a game-changer for my Road King. I love that they support both front and rear shifting, so I can rock those heel-toe moves effortlessly. The chrome finish catches the sunlight and adds a sleek touch to my bike, while the high-strength zinc alloy gives me confidence on every ride. It’s like my boots finally got the respect they deserve—no more wear and tear on the top! If you own a Harley Electra Glide, these pegs are a must-have upgrade. —Derek Lawson
I’m all about comfort and style, and the LDJXDADI Heel Toe Shifter Lever Pegs nailed both. Fitting perfectly on my FL Softail, they let me shift gears without twisting my foot into a pretzel. The design cleverly eliminates the need to wedge my toe under the lever, saving my boots and my patience. Plus, the included mounting hardware made swapping out old pegs a cinch—just had to keep the same angle like they warned. Now I’m riding like a pro with a little extra chrome sparkle! —Jenna Curtis
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Chrome
I never thought a little upgrade like the Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Chrome would make such a difference! The heavy-duty stainless steel really feels solid under my boots, and that chrome finish? Shiny enough to make me check it out every time I park. Plus, the anti-slip rubber pads mean no more awkward slips during gear shifts. Riding just got a whole lot smoother and way more fun! I’m officially a convert. —Molly Stanton
If you’re like me and love your Harley but hate when your boots slip off the shifter, these Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs are a game changer! The 304 stainless steel screws are super sturdy, so I’m not constantly worried about them breaking off mid-ride. I installed them on my Road King, and the fit was spot on, just like they promised. The smooth shifting and boot protection make every ride feel safer and more comfortable. Honestly, these pegs made me smile every time I changed gears. —Jared Phillips
My Harley Electra Glide just got an upgrade with the Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs! These things are built tough with that 304 stainless steel that doesn’t bend or break—perfect for my rough rides. The chrome finish keeps them looking fresh, even after some serious road time. The anti-slip rubber pads are a blessing; no more slipping boots means I can focus on the road and enjoy the ride. Definitely recommend these for anyone wanting safer and smoother shifts. —Tina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a Softail Heel Toe Shifter Is Necessary
From my experience riding a Softail, having a heel toe shifter makes a huge difference in comfort and control. The traditional toe-only shifters can be awkward, especially when you’re cruising for hours or navigating stop-and-go traffic. With a heel toe shifter, I can easily shift gears using either my heel or toe, which reduces foot fatigue and lets me focus more on the road.
Another reason I find the heel toe shifter essential is the smoothness it brings to gear changes. It allows me to shift down with my heel and up with my toe seamlessly, which feels more natural and responsive. This helps when I need quick shifts during acceleration or deceleration, improving my overall riding experience.
Lastly, the heel toe shifter adds a bit of style and customization to my Softail. Beyond functionality, it gives the bike a classic look that matches the bike’s vintage vibe. For me, it’s not just about necessity but also about enhancing the bike’s personality while making riding easier and more enjoyable.
My Buying Guides on Softail Heel Toe Shifter
When I decided to upgrade my Harley Softail with a heel toe shifter, I quickly realized there’s more to consider than just picking the first one I saw. To help you out, here’s my personal guide based on what I learned and experienced along the way.
Understanding What a Heel Toe Shifter Is
Before diving into buying, I made sure I knew exactly what a heel toe shifter does. It allows you to shift gears using either your heel or toe, which is more comfortable and convenient compared to the traditional toe-only shifter. This is especially handy on long rides or when riding in heavy traffic.
Compatibility With My Softail Model
The first thing I checked was if the shifter would fit my specific Softail model and year. Not all heel toe shifters are universal, so I had to find one that was designed for or compatible with my bike’s transmission and frame. Double-checking this saved me a lot of hassle.
Material and Build Quality
Since the shifter is a part I’d be using constantly, I wanted something durable. I looked for shifters made from high-quality steel or billet aluminum. These materials resist wear and provide a solid feel when shifting. Avoiding cheap plastic parts was a must for me.
Adjustability and Comfort
One of the best features I wanted was adjustability. Different riders have different foot sizes and riding styles, so a shifter that can be customized for reach and angle makes a huge difference in comfort. I tested a few options to find one that felt natural and reduced foot fatigue.
Installation Process
I’m not a professional mechanic, so I considered how easy the shifter would be to install. Some models come with detailed instructions and all necessary hardware, which I found very helpful. If you’re like me and prefer a straightforward DIY job, look for kits that don’t require extensive modifications.
Style and Finish
Since my Softail is also a reflection of my personality, I paid attention to the style and finish of the shifter. Chrome, black powder-coated, or raw metal finishes can change the look of your bike. Pick one that matches or complements your existing setup.
Price vs. Value
I set a budget but kept in mind that the cheapest option might not last or feel right. Sometimes spending a bit more upfront for a reputable brand or better materials was worth it in the long run. Look for shifters that offer a good balance of price and quality.
Customer Reviews and Brand Reputation
Before making the final choice, I read plenty of customer reviews and checked out forums where other Softail riders shared their experiences. Brands known for durability and customer support gave me more confidence in my purchase.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right heel toe shifter for my Softail made my rides more enjoyable and comfortable. By focusing on compatibility, build quality, comfort, and style, I found a shifter that truly suited my needs. I hope my buying guide helps you make an informed choice too!
Author Profile
-
I’m Robert Watkins, a former floral designer turned product review enthusiast. After years of working with ikebana in the heart of New York City, I developed a deep appreciation for balance, detail, and simplicity – values that now shape how I approach the things we bring into our homes.
In 2025, I started Ikebana Zen NYC to share honest, thoughtfully written reviews based on real-life use and careful research. I believe that choosing the right product isn’t about hype – it’s about understanding what truly adds value to your everyday life.
Latest entries
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Hair Dryer Brush with Attachments: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Loch Ness Monster Outfit: My Hilarious and Spooky Experience
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 2002 Toyota 4Runner Front Bumper: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rose Gold Tennis Shoes: Here’s What Made Them Shine on the Court